Although my main interest in wound management is with regard to thyroidectomy incisions, the questions, concepts and principles apply to most clean surgical wounds.
Question 1: When can I get my incision wet?
In 48 hours. Twenty-five years ago, I used to recommend not getting surgical wounds wet for seven days. Over the years I have steadily reduced this time to two full days and have noticed no difference in healing or wound infections. The above recommendations are for clean surgical wounds with direct closure. I also advise that surgical drain sites are kept dry for two to three days after removal of the drain, depending on the size of the drain site.
I am a lot more conservative if there is an underlying bone fracture or osteotomy. I like to keep skin grafts undisturbed for two weeks.
Question 2: Is sunlight good for my scar?
The short answer is keep the wound out of the sun for nine months. Most authorities recommend no exposure of fresh wounds to sunlight for six to 12 months.
Sunlight can cause post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, resulting in the wound being darker or redder than the surrounding skin. For a wound to disappear, it needs to be flat, thin, preferably in a skin crease and the same colour as the surrounding skin. A dark or red wound will be highly visible.
While it is true that ultraviolet light can assist in wound healing, the beneficial effect of ultraviolet light on wound healing is dose dependent. Ultraviolet light is bactericidal; it also dries the wound. UVA rays penetrate quite deeply and can damage collagen. Low-dose ultraviolet light (photobiomodulation) can reduce inflammation, relieve pain and promote tissue regeneration. The problem with ultraviolet light and wound healing is controlling the dose of ultraviolet light and, therefore, most authorities recommend avoiding exposing a fresh wound to sunlight.
Question 3: What can I do to prevent scarring?
Silicone tape. The European guidelines for the management of surgical wounds recommend silicone taping of wounds as soon as the wound has healed.
There is widespread support for this approach in the medical literature. It is recommended that silicone taping be performed for a minimum of 12 hours and preferably 24 hours a day for three months or longer. The silicone tape should extend 2.5cm beyond the wound in all directions. Silicone tape and sheets can be purchased through pharmacies or online. Silicone is also available as a gel, but the efficacy of silicone gel in wound management is not as well established as silicone tape and sheets. However, silicone gel is often more convenient for people with scars on their faces.
Silicone taping works by distributing the force of tension across a larger area, thereby decreasing tension on the wound. Silicone taping also helps to flatten wounds and keep wounds moist.
At the time of surgery, it is a good idea to apply porous paper tape or Steri-Strips across the wound to help distribute healing forces, start flattening the wound and keep the wound moist.
Question 4: What about cream or oil to help the scar disappear?
The main objective here is to keep the scar moist. While there is a myriad of products available, they all endeavour to keep the scar moist and prevent the scar from drying out. A simple moisturiser is all that is required. Use a moisturiser that suits you. Silicone gel can also be used. Some people recommend vitamin E cream, aloe vera cream, Mederma, products containing onion extract or green tea extract, and there is some level 1 evidence supporting some of these products3
Moisturisers can aid wound massage. Moisturisers may also interfere with the attachment of silicone taping.
Question 5: What about massaging the scar?
This is probably a good idea. Advocates of wound massage recommend massaging the wound after it has fully healed. Various techniques are described, with the most common techniques advocated being massaging parallel to the long axis of the wound, including directing over the wound and massaging in a circular fashion over the wound. Massaging the scar can be performed with or without the use of a cream or moisturiser. Advocates of wound massage claim that it helps to disperse the healing reaction and align collagen bundles, thereby improving the appearance and flexibility of the scar.
Summary
There is good evidence to support the use of silicone taping and avoidance of exposure to sunlight to minimise the appearance of a surgical scar. Regular use of a moisturiser and massaging the scar are also sensible options.
References:
1. Téot L, Mustoe TA, Middelkoop E, Gauglitz GG, editors. Textbook on Scar Management. Springer; 2020. Open Access. Available online.
2. Mustoe TA, et al. International Clinical Recommendations on Scar Management. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002 Aug; 110(2): 560–71.
3. Basson R, Bayat A. Skin scarring: Latest update on objective assessment and optimal management. Front Med. 2022 Oct 5;9: 942756. doi:10.3389/fmed.2022.942756.